Monday, February 14, 2011

AMS Act Three Reading Journal

 In act three, the ending comes.
Chris has been out all night and no-one knows where he is.
Jim tells Kate he'll come home because he's a good son.
It's all a bit depressing, really.
Joe dies.   Yeah...  It was suicide.  I think really that takes all hope of him ever being a tragic hero away.  TRAGIC HEROES DO NOT KILL THEMSELVES.  Hmph.
That is basically the general opinion that I have, and I'm struggling to get past it to make a comment of any value.
The ENTIRE ACT completely DESTROYS the feeling of TRAGEDY and DESPAIR.
Yes, he kills himself.
HOWEVER, that's not tragic, because he wasn't a very nice man.
All we get at the end of this is a feeling that maybe Chris and Ann can be happy now because he's dead and so they won't have to have the burden of him being a shit between them for the rest of their lives.
Kate doesn't exactly act all depressy either, like normal people would if their husband died.  So what the hell, really?

1 comment:

  1. Why can't a tragic hero take his own life? Isn't Kate being brave to allow the family to re-build? Hasn't the issue of deceit now been resolved? Do you think Miller has achieved his aim of writing a tragedy for ordinary people?

    ReplyDelete